Choose From  Our Many Mitchell’s Ice Cream Products

Cups & Cones
Taste the difference. We make super-premium ice cream, made with 16% butterfat, and that’s what makes our ice cream taste so rich and creamy. With over 40 flavors to choose from, there’s always something new to try. Whether it’s on a waffle cone, sugar cone, plain cone, waffle bowl, or in a cup, the options are endless. Call us at (415) 648-2300 to ask about specific flavors if you have a gluten or egg allergy.
Sundaes & Splits
Get creative! Order an ice cream sundae or banana split any way you want it. Choose your flavors and toppings, which include hot fudge, caramel, mango, strawberry, chocolate, marshmallow and pineapple.  With a mound of our homemade whipped cream and a cherry on top, we’re sure it’ll make your day!
Choose from any of our 40 fabulous flavors for our 16 oz. and 24 oz. custom blended milkshakes. We’ll make your shake just the way you like it, and for an added treat, top it off with our homemade whipped cream. We also make ice cream floats and freezes. We have something for everyone!
Ice Cream Cakes
Mitchell’s will no longer be taking custom cake orders as of November 28, 2023. We will continue to make stock cakes that you may pick up at our store (688 San Jose Ave., S.F.) in the following flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Mango, and Thin Mint. Simple greetings can be added to these cakes. Please accept our apologies for this inconvenience.
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Our ice cream sandwiches are made to order, with freshly baked cookies and your choice of ice cream. Mmmmmm good!
guava sorbet
We make our sorbets from scratch using the finest fruit purées available, along with cane sugar and water They are dairy free and make a refreshing and indulgent dessert. Please call us at (415) 648-2300 for current availability of flavors.
Vegan Ice Cream
We make our Vegan ice cream with Oatly Oat Milk.  Our Vegan flavors are 100% dairy free and incredibly delicious!  Please call us at (415) 648-2300 for our current availability of flavors.
Seasonal Eggnog Drink
We make our super-rich and creamy Eggnog drink with cream, sugar, eggs and rum flavoring. It’s only available during the holiday season, from November until early January. We think you’ll agree it’s one great way to celebrate the Holidays!